Showing posts with label James Somers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label James Somers. Show all posts

Wednesday, 8 February 2012

The influence of augmented feedback and prior learning on the acquisition of a new bimanual coordination pattern

This paper focuses on the affects of two variables when learning a new bimanual coordination pattern; previous experiences and augmented feedback techniques. The main aim of this study is to acquire the new coordination pattern 135˚ relative phase.

Two different types of augmented feedback were compared, visual pursuit tracking and terminal feedback. Terminal augmented feedback consists of a static target lissajous figure combined with actual movement after each trial. Pursuit tracking consists of a static trace of the target lissajous, a dynamic trace of the learner’s movement during the trials and a target moving around the lissajous figure in time with the auditory metronome of 1Hz.


Participants practiced either 90˚ or 135˚ relative phase in two learning sessions and were randomly assigned to a group:

Sessions one and two:
Group 1 – practiced 90˚ relative phase with pursuit tracking
Group 2 – practiced 135˚ relative phase with pursuit tracking
Group 3 – practiced 90˚ relative phase with terminal feedback
Group 4 – practiced 135˚ relative phase with terminal feedback

In session three all four groups performed 30 trials of 135˚ lasting 20 seconds using the same feedback as in previous sessions.

Participants grasped two linear sliding devices parallel to the table and displacements were calculated. Two monitors were used to display the feedback depending on which group you were in.


Generally speaking when trying to perform a novel task most people are biased towards anti phase 180˚. In this case the groups that practiced the 90˚ pattern performed the transfer 135˚ pattern more poorly and were strongly biased towards the newly learned 90˚ pattern. During transfer the pursuit tracking groups performed with a higher mean relative phase (129.6) than the terminal feedback groups (114.9). Following two sessions of practice 90˚ pattern, performance of the transfer pattern was facilitated by pursuit tracking to a much greater extent than terminal feedback. It was suggested that pursuit tracking feedback encouraged the learner to focus on matching the lissajous figures rather than their moving limbs. This supports Wulf and Prinz (2001) who stated that performance and learning benefits if the learner focuses on the environmental effects rather than the movement itself.


WULF, G., & W. PRINZ. 2001. Directing attention to movement effects enhances learning: A review. Psychonomic bulletin & review. 8, pp. 648-660.

HURLEY, S.R., & T.D. LEE. 2006. The influence of augmented feedback and prior learning on the acquisition of a new bimanual coordination pattern. Human movement science. 25, pp.339-348.

Friday, 28 October 2011

Perceptual Learning Immediately Yields New Stable Motor Coordination

The reason 0° is easy while other relative phases are hard is that the requisite information is detected most readily at 0°. This test predicts that if a participant were to improve their ability to detect the requisite information then their movement stability would improve.

There were 12 participants. Half the participants were assigned to the Experimental Group and half to the Control. There were two types of experimental task: two alternative forced choice (2AFC) judgements, and coordinated rhythmic movement. There were then two types of session:

1. Assessment sessions consisted of both judgement trials (at both 90° and 180°) and movement trials (moving at 0°, 90°, and 180°). There was no feedback.

2. Training consisted only of judgement trials at 90° with feedback.

The Experimental group did three assessment sessions and up to 14 training sessions. The Control group did three sessions of movement trials, with no training or feedback.
Judgements (Perceptual Ability)
Participants had to identify a target phase of 90° in a pair of displays. Participants then trained with progressively harder perceptual discriminations around 90° with feedback.
Movement Stability (Baseline, Post Training and Retention)
Participants used a joystick to coordinate the movement of two dots on a screen at three relative phases. Participants were instructed to move so as to produce a mean relative phase of 0°, 180°, or 90°, three trials of each.
A repeated measures ANOVA was used to check the significance between the two groups. Significant differences were found in the experimental group which shows that perceptual training was successful. The movement task found that only participants in the Experimental group improved their movement stability across sessions and this improvement was restricted to 90°.
To conclude participants in this experiment improved their movement stability at 90° following training to improve their perceptual ability at 90°. Also improved perceptual discrimination of 90° led to improved performance in the movement task at 90° with no training. The improvement persisted until Retention without further exposure to either task.

Friday, 14 October 2011

Learning a coordinated rhythmic movement with task appropriate coordination feedback

The aim of this study is to produce a novel coordinated rhythmic movement (90˚ mean relative phase) using coordination feedback during post training. This allows the participant to learn a novel task. This should not alter in any way the perceptual information. It is said that people cannot produce 90˚ novel movements stably without training. They can only produce two stable coordination patterns without training, 0˚ and 180˚. So progression and learning has to occur, in this case coordination feedback is used.


10 participants were split into two groups of five. Group 1 (‘Feedback’) received coordination feedback during training; Group 2 (‘No Feedback’) received no feedback but an equal exposure to the task.


There were two assessment sessions (Baseline and Post-training) and five training sessions. Participants viewed a demo of the target relative phase and then performed five trials. In the five training sessions participants performed ten 20 sec trials with a target mean relative phase of 90˚. There was a computer-controlled dot situated above the person-controlled dot. The participants then used a joystick to move the dot at a specific mean relative phase. For the Feedback group feedback was provided by the colour change of the person-controlled dot from white to green when the participant was moving at 90˚, ± an error bandwidth. In the first session the error bandwidth was set to 40˚. Any performance between 50˚ and 130˚ triggered the colour change. The bandwidth was decreased in each session to 30˚, 20˚, 15˚ and 10˚. This will drive learning as the participant improves after each bandwidth. A colour change was used as the coordinated feedback because it is said that colour has no affect on movement stability. The No Feedback group also did 50 trials, but with no feedback.


A repeated measures ANOVA was used. The results found that participants who received coordination feedback successfully and significantly improved their ability to maintain 90˚ coordination. The No Feedback group showed no improvement at any mean relative phase. Coordination feedback does not alter or remove the visual information (relative direction). Unlike visual metronomes and Lissajous figures which do alter the perceptual information.


People do not tend to suddenly acquire 90˚, as they are unable to move at 90˚ long enough to allow the required perceptual learning. The control group in this experiment received extensive practice at 90˚, but no help identifying when they were moving correctly, so failed to learn this coordination.